
Kat Jones

Colloidal minerals and trace elements have been stirring quite a bit of controversy recently. Some say they have nutritional benefits to the health, and others say they are useless, and potentially even hazardous. As the dictionary states, colloidal minerals are "aggregates of atoms or molecules in a finely divided state dispersed in a gaseous, liquid or solid medium and resisting sedimentation, diffusion and filtration." What this means is that colloidal minerals are stable aggregates, in other words, the colloids are extremely atomic. Since they are aggregates at least two atoms, the colloid still contains a minimum of two ions even if it's in the ionic state. This is not a reasonable purpose for the use of colloids when we can use exceptional and more affordable ionic mineral sources and receive single ions with more nutritional benefits. This is much simpler than dealing with colloids, as we may have to deal with many minerals at a time. Instead, the body gets exactly what it is looking for by dealing with one mineral at a time.
Colloidal minerals and trace elements do not have the benefits that some may claim they have. They are in fact relatively useless. It is not hard to see the chances are that the aggregates of ions will not be absorbed by the body. Colloidal minerals and trace elements were never meant to be a nutritional supplement. There are absolutely no studies that show anything about the absorption of colloids, it's nutritional benefits, or its effects on metabolism and digestion.
Colloidal minerals and trace elements become popular in medicine in the early 1900's and continued to be a part of this trend until around 1936. They were discovered when physicians found they could use silver in a state of dispersion as an antibiotic. Colloids were very commonly used for this purpose back in these days as it was before the discovery and inventions of modern conventional antibiotics. Around 1935 to 1936, the discovery of more efficient conventional antibiotics came about and the supposed benefits of colloidal minerals were pushed to the back wall. The last evidence of scientific papers on the benefits of colloidal miners and trace elements are from the early 30's. There are no known papers on colloids since 1936, where the trend ended. Although more efficient antibiotics are now in place, it is still important to know about colloidal minerals and trace elements when used as antibiotics and nutritional supplements. What we do know is that colloidal minerals and trace elements are not likely to be absorbed efficiently by the body, are unlikely to have nutritional benefits, and may even prove to be toxic when taken daily.
Colloidal Minerals and trace elements have earned some fame and unrealistic claims surrounding them. Without any evidence to back it up, there are many claims of nutritional benefits of colloidal minerals and trace elements. Some people even claim that colloidal minerals are 98 percent absorbed by the body. Without scientific support, there is no reason to believe this claim as the literature dating back to as far as 1905 shows no evidence to back it up. There are two reasons these people believe this unrealistic claim is true.
The first reason is because colloid particles are very small. This leads believers to think that they are easily absorbed, although this is not the case. Ions are smaller than colloids. The transporter uptake proteins are searching for ions by themselves, so it is very unlikely that they will be absorbed so easily. Claims that state 98 percent of colloids are absorbed and only eight to ten percent of ionized minerals are absorbed are just dead wrong. The only reasons anyone would make these claims are because they have not seen the literature or they are purposely ignoring it or misrepresenting it because the literature very clearly shows that, depending on the body's hunger for a certain mineral, the nutritional absorption rate in the ionic form is between a range of 20 to 90 percent. When the body is hungry for the certain mineral, the absorption rate goes up. It works just the opposite when the body has adequate amounts of the certain mineral, then the rate of absorption decreases.
The other reason for these claims is that they believe these minerals are attracted to the stomach therefore leading to nutritional benefits. The belief is that the minerals are negatively charged and the stomach is positively charged, causing the two to be attracted to each other. This is simply not true as it is common knowledge that the stomach has a very negative charge. This also does not prove any nutritional benefits of colloidal minerals and trace elements.
Overall, the claims surrounding colloidal minerals and trace elements and their nutritional benefits contradict scientific evidence, therefore they cannot be true. The hype about colloids is nothing but a trend, and the nutritional benefits are slim to none. Colloidal minerals and trace elements are difficult for the body to absorb. Simple single ionic mineral sources are much easier for the body to absorb and a much better use of your money.
Our Recommended Picks
Leave a comment
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
0 Comments
No Comments yet! Be the first to start a conversation
Further Reading
Celebrate Earth Day with 10% Off - 48 Hours Only
Celebrate Earth Day 2025 with 10% off SITEWIDE with code “EARTH25” Offer only valid for 48 hours - 9 A.M. 4/23/2025 through 9 A.M. 4/25/2025 MDT Save on your last-minute spring garden needs! Seeds, supplies, and more! This deal won’t last long. What is...
Ashleigh Smith
2025-04-232 min read0Living on the Edge: 10+ Edible Plants for Landscape Borders
Written By Lara Wadsworth Why settle for pretty when your garden and landscape borders can be tasty too? If you’ve ever met me, you know that I love beautiful plants that are also utilitanian. Plants that feed the soil, feed me, or promote pollinators ...
Ashleigh Smith
2025-04-237 min read0Growing Microgreens at Home: A Beginner's Experience
Written By Lara Wadsworth Microgreens seem to be used at every gourmet restaurant, are being talked about in every health magazine, and are having more and more scientific research released about the purported health benefits of these little plants. Wh...
Ashleigh Smith
2025-04-1510 min read0How to Harden Off Seedlings in 5 Easy Steps
Written By Lara Wadsworth Hardening off is the process of gradually exposing your seedlings to new outdoor conditions to help them adjust without experiencing transplant shock. This is when a seedling becomes delayed, stunted, or even dies after being ...
Ashleigh Smith
2025-04-156 min read4